In judgment no. 2906/2026, published on 8 October 2026, the Florence Court of Appeal ruled on the appeal in the dispute between the Italian Ministry of Culture and Netflix Services Italy, Eagle Pictures and Panorama Films. The case concerns the scene in 6 Underground in which Michelangelo’s David appears.
In 2022, the Italian Ministry of Culture sued Netflix Services Italy and the local production services companies (Eagle Pictures, Panorama) over a 25-second scene in 6 Underground (timestamp: 16:55) showing Michelangelo’s David.
There are two issues:
Image use. Italian law protects certain cultural heritage assets, including public-domain works, and requires prior authorization and a fee for commercial use.
The museum asked for EUR 400k, which also covered shooting access. Instead of paying the fee, Netflix decide to add the scene in post-production without authorization from the Museum.
“Denigration.” In the scene, the characters joke about the size of David’s genitals (transcript: “Is the David the one with the really small…” “Yep, that’s it” “You wanna get out and compare, or should we maybe think about going?”). Ministry insisted on removal of the scene or title. In 2024 the First Instance Court issued an injunction and ordered Netflix, Eagle Pictures and Panorama to pay damages (EUR 1.02m).
The Court of Appeal orders Netflix Italy to remove the scene in Italy, with a penalty of EUR 30k per day of non-compliance. Moreover the Court of Appeal orders Netflix Italy and the co-defendants to: (i) pay EUR 420k: EUR 320k for lack of authorization and EUR 100k (down from EUR 700k) for non-pecuniary damages for “denigration” of David and “harm to the collective identity the work embodies”; (ii) publish the operative part in three newspapers (Corriere della Sera, Il Venerdì di Repubblica, Corriere Fiorentino).
On the merits, the Court held that Articles 107 and 108 of the Italian Cultural Heritage Code establish an image right in cultural property. This protection continues after copyright has expired (Article 32-quater of the Copyright Act). The Court refused both to refer a question to the Constitutional Court and to make a preliminary reference to the CJEU. In the field of culture the EU has only supporting competence (Articles 6 and 167 TFEU), and Directive 2019/1024 allows museums to charge for re-use. The Court described Articles 107–108 as legislation whose content is “constitutionally mandated” and referred expressly to the controlimiti doctrine. A digital reproduction made without contact with the original still falls under Article 107(2), because it has the effect of a cast. The EUR 400,000 fee was not an abuse of right: the ordinary courts may review the museum director’s discretion only for legality.
On the denigration claim, the Court recognised a second protected interest alongside the image right: the “collective identity” that the work embodies (Articles 2 and 9 of the Constitution and Article 1 of the Code). The State acts as the institutional representative of that interest. The scene is not protected as satire, because it expresses no “reasoned dissent” from the values the David represents.
On remedies, the appeal was partly upheld:
- Injunction: limited to the sequences in which the David appears. Blocking the entire film was held disproportionate.
- Penalty: confirmed at EUR 30,000 per day, because it had not been specifically challenged.
- Pecuniary damages: confirmed at EUR 320,000, i.e. the fee requested less EUR 80,000 for filming that the Galleria never had to host.
- Non-pecuniary damages: reduced from EUR 700,000 to EUR 100,000. The Court used the Milan Tribunal tables and awarded close to twice their maximum. The Ministry’s cross-appeal, which sought EUR 3.2 million, was dismissed.
- Publication: an extract of the judgment must be published once, in ordinary type, in Corriere della Sera, Il Venerdì di Repubblica and Corriere Fiorentino, including their online editions, and on the websites and social media pages of the three companies, within ninety days. If the companies fail to do so, the Ministry may publish it at their expense.
The anonymised text of the judgment is available here.